Eugen Fischer, PD Dr.

 

 

Curriculum VitaeResearch InterestsPublicationsWork in ProgressBook Abstracts

 

 

Contact

Philosophie-Department

Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität

Geschwister-Scholl-Platz 1

D-80539 München

 

Eugen.Fischer@lrz.uni-muenchen.de

Tel.: +49 89 2180 3829

Office: Theresienstr. 39, E034

 

 

Curriculum Vitae

Eugen Fischer, born 1970, obtained the degrees of BPhil (1993) and DPhil (1996) in philosophy at Oxford and the Habilitation (2002) at Munich, where he has been teaching since 1997 and currently holds the position of Senior Lecturer (C2) in philosophy and a Heisenberg Research Readership (funded by the German Research Council DFG). He was a Visiting Scholar at New York University (1998) and has been awarded a Golestan Fellowship at the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study (for 2005/6). At Munich he served (from 1999-2001) as Founding Executive Director of the new MPhil-programme in philosophy.

 

 

Research Interests

in the areas of philosophy of mind and language, epistemology and metaphysics, metaphilosophy, philosophy of mental health; 20th-century analytic philosophy, early modern philosophy, Plato. In particular:

 

-         linguistic understanding and semantic knowledge

-         visual perception and ‘experience’

-         cognitive distortions and psychosis

 

-         Wittgenstein and the ‘Austro-British’ strand of analytic philosophy

-         Berkeley and early modern philosophy of perception

 

 

Publications:

 

– Books Authored

 

(1)          Linguistic Creativity. Dordrecht and Boston: Kluwer, 2000

English Abstract below

(2)          Philosophical Delusion and its Therapy. London and New York: Routledge, accepted, and scheduled for publication in 2006

English Abstract below

 

– Edited Volumes

 

(3)          Eugen Fischer & Wilhelm Vossenkuhl: Die Fragen der Philosophie. Eine Einführung in Disziplinen und Epochen (The Questions of Philosophy. An Introduction to Areas and Periods). München: C.H.Beck, 2003

German Abstract below

(4)          Erich Ammereller & Eugen Fischer: Wittgenstein at Work. Method in the “Philosophical Investigations”. London: Routledge, 2004

English Abstract below

 

– Published Papers

 

(1)          On the Very Idea of a Theory of Meaning for a Natural Language, Synthese, vol. 111 (no.1), April 1997, pp. 1-16

(2)          Dissolving Problems of Linguistic Creativity, Philosophical Investigations, vol. 20 (no.4), October 1997, pp. 290-314

(3)          Platos Untersuchung der Formen der Tugend: Eine Fallstudie zur Frage: Was ist und was soll nicht-deskriptive Metaphysik? (Plato’s Inquiry into the Forms of Virtue: A Case-Study on Nature and Point of Non-descriptive Metaphysics). Philosophisches Jahrbuch, vol. 107 (no. 1), April 2000, pp. 95-115

(4)          Unfair to Physiology, Acta Analytica, vol. 16 (no.26), July 2001, pp. 135-55

(5)          Discrimination: A Challenge to First-Person Authority?, Philosophical Investigations, vol. 24 (no.4), October 2001, pp. 330-46

(6)          Bogus Finitude, Forschungsberichte des Instituts für Phonetik und Sprachliche Kommunikation München, vol. 37, 2001, pp. 111-26

(7)          A Puzzle about Colour Discrimination, in: A.Beckermann & C.Nimtz (eds): Argument and Analysis. Selected Papers Contributed to the 4th International Congress of the Society for Analytic Philosophy, Paderborn: Mentis, 2002

(8)          Bogus Mystery about Linguistic Competence, Synthese, vol. 135 (no.1), April 2003, pp. 49-75

(9)          Philosophie des Geistes: Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung gegen menschliches Selbstbild (Philosophy of Mind: Scientific World-View vs. Human Self-Conception), in: E.Fischer & W.Vossenkuhl (eds): Die Fragen der Philosophie, München: C.H.Beck, 2003, pp. 70-88

(10)  Was ist Philosophie? (What Is Philosophy?), with W.Vossenkuhl, in: E.Fischer & W.Vossenkuhl (eds): Die Fragen der Philosophie, München: C.H.Beck, 2003, pp. 7-14

(11)  A Cognitive Self-Therapy – Philosophical Investigations sections 138-97, in: E.Ammereller & E.Fischer (eds): Wittgenstein at Work. Method in the “Philosophical Investigations”, London: Routledge, 2004, pp. 86-126

(12)  Aims and Method in the Investigations, with E. Ammereller, in: E.Ammereller & E.Fischer (eds): Wittgenstein at Work, London: Routledge, 2004, pp. ix-xix

(13)  Traumskepsis: Von der Illusion einer Lösung zum Ansatz einer Auflösung (Dream Scepticism: From an Illusory Solution to the Outline of a Dissolution), in: R. Bluhm & C. Nimtz (eds.): Philosophy and/as Science. Selected Papers Contributed to the 5th International Congress of the Society for Analytic Philosophy, Paderborn: Mentis, 2004, pp. 182-92

(14)   Empfindungen: Wittgensteins Analyse eines philosophischen ‘Triebes’ (Imaginary Experiences: Wittgenstein’s Analysis of a Philosophical ‘Urge’), in: M. Reicher et al. (eds.): Experience and Analysis. Proceedings of the 27th International Wittgenstein Symposium, Vienna: öbv&hpt, 2004

(15)  Austin on Sense-Data: Ordinary Language Analysis as ‘Therapy’, accepted and forthcoming in: Grazer Philosophische Studien, vol. 70, October 2005

(16)  Beunruhigende Analogien: Was Wittgenstein Warum Will (Disquieting Analogies: What Wittgenstein Wants Why), commissioned paper forthcoming in: Wittgenstein-Studies

(17)  Wittgensteins „Big Typescript“ über Bedeutung: Philosophie als Therapie ohne Theorie (Wittgenstein’s ‘Big Typescript’ on Meaning: Philosophy as Therapy without Theory), forthcoming in: Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie

 

Papers under Review and Work in Progress

 

(18) Philosophical Pictures, under review

(19) Wittgenstein’s Non-Cognitivism, under review

 

(20) Berkeley’s ‘Arguments’ for Idealism, work in progress

(21) Berkeley et al. on Immediate Perception, work in progress

(22) The Concept of Delusion, work in progress

(23) Understanding Psychosis: What Cognitive Models Can Do, work in progress

 

 

Book Abstracts

 

(1)          Linguistic Creativity. Exercises in ‘Philosophical Therapy’. Dordrecht and Boston: Kluwer, 2000

vol.81 of the Philosophical Studies Series, ed. by Keith Lehrer

 

Publisher’s abstract

How is it that speakers can get to know the meaning of any of indefinitely many sentences they have never encountered before? – The ‘problem of linguistic creativity’ posed by this question is a core problem of both philosophy of language and theoretical linguistics, and has sparked off a considerable amount of work in the philosophy of mind. The book establishes the failure of the familiar – compositional – approach to this problem, and then takes a radically new start: It develops core elements of the later Wittgenstein’s conception of philosophy, and puts them to work to ‘dissolve’ the problem, to prove it ill-framed by clarifying the questions posing it and breaking the spell of mistaken analogies informing it. This sharply focused monograph thus has a two-fold aim: to cope with a crucial problem that turns out to be a lot tougher than generally thought; and to present a precise and rigorous demonstration of an unfamiliar and exciting philosophical approach. (193+xiv pp.)

 

Content

 

Part I

The Problem: Ch.1 The Orthodox Perspective: A Problem of Linguistic Creativity, Ch.2 The Philosophical Problem: The Plight of Orthodoxy.

Part II

New Methods: Ch.3 Philosophical Dissolution: Unintelligible Questions, Ch.4 Philosophical Therapy: A Sense of Wonder and a Change of Aspect

Part III

A Therapy: Ch. 5 Semantic Creativity: The Philosophical Problem Again, Ch.6 Semantic Creativity: Problem-Dissolution and Therapy. Postscript: Dissolving Philosophical Problems

 

(2)          Philosophical Delusion and its Therapy. A Metaphilosophical Inquiry. London and New York: Routledge, accepted and scheduled for publication in 2006

 

Author’s Abstract

Many important philosophical problems arise from the impression that there is a tension between different claims philosophers feel equally compelled to accept: Our self conception as free and rational agents appears to conflict with the scientific world-view of modernity, giving rise to mind-body problems; the claim that all we directly perceive are immaterial sense-data appears to contradict common sense, etc. Philosophers sympathetic to both sides typically try to reconcile what appears to be at odds. Such ‘reconciliation problems’, however, are frequently raised without good reason: all too often we lack all warrant either for the claims to be reconciled or for the impression of a tension between them. The book documents that, and examines how, competent thinkers are systematically driven to formulate such poor problems: how they leap, on the sketchiest of ‘grounds’, to unwarranted or even downright absurd claims, and maintain them even once they have realised that all the arguments adduced for them fail. Philosophical Delusion and its Therapy analyses, first, how competent thinkers may come to systematically develop and maintain such delusions. Second, it develops a therapeutic approach to rid us of pertinent delusions and resolve the problems they (appear to) generate. To both ends, the book adapts notions from cognitive approaches in clinical psychology, on the one hand, and from Ludwig Wittgenstein and J.L.Austin, on the other. The metaphilosophical argument is developed by analysing two sets of philosophical problems, chosen to cover four core areas of philosophy: the epistemological and metaphysical problems addressed and generated by the sense-datum doctrine of perception; and a set of problems at the intersection of the philosophies of mind and language, about linguistic understanding (instantaneous understanding and linguistic creativity). The analysis is developed through a series of case studies, covering thinkers representative of different philosophical traditions: Berkeley, A.J.Ayer, Wittgenstein, and a group of Oxford philosophers equally influenced by Frege and Wittgenstein. The concluding Outlook outlines how the concepts developed might be applied to metaphysical mind-body problems. In this way, Philosophical Delusion and its Therapy develops a novel account of the nature and genesis of a core class of philosophical problems: reconciliation problems. On this basis, it establishes precisely where and why therapy is called for in philosophy, and develops a set of diagnostic and therapeutic techniques: a rigorous method of philosophical therapy. (ca. 300 pp., incl. index)

 

Content

 

 

Ch.0 Introduction

 

Part I – The Need for Therapy

Ch.1 An Early Modern Vision

Ch.2 Ayer’s Delusion

Ch.3 The Therapeutic Turn

 

Part II – Models of Therapy

Ch.4 Austin’s Response to Ayer

Ch.5 Cognitive Therapy

Ch. 6 Wittgenstein’s Self-Therapy

 

Part III – Methods of Therapy

Ch. 7 Determining Meaning

Ch. 8 Switching Analogies

Ch.9 A Comprehensive Intervention

 

 

 

Ch.10 Recapitulation and Outlook

 

(3)          Eugen Fischer & Wilhelm Vossenkuhl (Hgg.): Die Fragen der Philosophie. Eine Einführung in Disziplinen und Epochen. München: C.H.Beck, 2003

 

abstract der herausgeber (redigiertes Verlagsabstract)

Diese Einführung gibt knapp, aber umfassend eine zugleich systematische und historische Problemübersicht, aus der das „Interesse“ der verschiedenen Disziplinen und der „Geist“ der verschiedenen Epochen der Philosophie hervorgeht. Im ersten Teil des Bandes werden die wichtigsten Disziplinen der Philosophie mit ihren Leitfragen und –problemen vorgestellt, im zweiten Teil die zentralen Epochen der Philosophiegeschichte mit den sie jeweils prägenden philosophischen Anliegen. Der Band gibt Studenten und allen an Philosophie Interessierten eine erste Antwort auf die Frage: Was ist und was soll Philosophie? (368 S.)

 

Inhalt

Einleitung: Was ist Philosophie? (E.Fischer & W.Vossenkuhl)

Erster Teil – Disziplinen der Philosophie

Ethik: Die Wissenschaft vom guten Handeln (W.Vossenkuhl), Politische Philosophie: Legitime Autorität und Gerechtigkeit (M.Rechenauer), Handlungstheorie: Was unser Handeln verursacht (S.Sellmaier), Philosophie des Geistes: Wissenschaftliche Weltauffassung gegen menschliches Selbstbild (E.Fischer), Sprachphilosophie: Die Flüchtigkeit der Bedeutung (J.Haag), Logik: Von Epimenides zu Gödel (G.Link & K.-G.Niebergall), Metaphysik: Die Tücken der Existenz (J.Hübner), Erkenntistheorie: Wissen, Meinen und Zweifel (S.Bernecker), Wissenschaftstheorie: Von Wesen und Struktur der Erfahrunsgwissenschaften (U.Moulines), Ästhetik: Von Gegenständen und Wahrnehmung der Kunst (A.Esser & J.Steinbrenner)

Zweiter Teil – Epochen der Philosophie

Ist wirklich dasselbe, was zu denken ist und was existiert? – Klassische griechische Philosophie (T.Buchheim), Die scholastische Form der Rationalität: Die Philosophie des Mittelalters (R.Schönberger), Die Entstehung der Neuzeit: Die Philosophie der Renaissance (E.Keßler), Das Licht der Vernunft und die Schatten des Zweifels: Der klassische rationalismus (U.Metschl), Allein aus Erfahrung wird man klug: Der klassische Empirismus (J.Kulenkampff), Die Möglichkeiten und Grenzen der Vernunft: Kant und der deutsche Idealismus (G.Zöller), Die Moderne als Herausforderung: Deutsche Philosophie von Nietzsche bis Heidegger (A.Reckermann), „Jedes Wort hat eine Bedeutung“: Analytische Philosophie von Frege bis Wittgenstein (D.Lotter), Der Logische Positivismus und seine Auflösung in der amerikanischen Nachkriegsphilosophie (D.Greimann)

 

(4)          Erich Ammereller & Eugen Fischer (eds.): Wittgenstein at Work. Method in the “Philosophical Investigations”. London: Routledge, 2004

 

Publisher’s Abstract

The later Wittgenstein is notoriously hard to understand. His novel philosophical approach is the key to understanding his perplexing work. This volume assembles leading Wittgenstein scholars to come to grips with its least well-understood aspect: the unfamiliar aims and method that shape Wittgenstein’s approach. Wittgenstein at Work investigates Wittgenstein’s aims, rationale, and method in two steps. The first seven chapters analyse how he proceeds in core parts of the Philosophical Investigations: the discussion of the Augustinian picture of language, ostensive definition, philosophical method, understanding, rule-following, and private language. The final five chapters examine his most striking methodological remarks: his repudiation of theory and non-trivial theses, and some core notions of his methodology: his notions of clarification, synoptic representation, nonsense, and philosophical pictures. The volume considerably advances discussion of the therapeutic aspects of his approach that are currently a focus of debate. This volume is an indispensable methodological companion to the Philosophical Investigations, useful to both specialists and students alike. (263+xxix pp., incl. index)

 

Content

Introduction: aims and method in the Investigations (E.Fischer & E.Ammereller)

Part I. Ch.1 Turning the examination around: the recantation of a metaphysician (P.M.S. Hacker), Ch.2 The builders’ language – the opening sections (J.Schulte), Ch.3 Diagnosis and therapy: christening simple objects – PI sections 38-64 (E.v.Savigny), Ch.4 Philosophy’s Hidden Essence – PI 89-133 (S.Mulhall), Ch.5 A cognitive self-therapy – PI 138-97 (E.Fischer), Ch.6 Puzzles about rule-following – PI 185-242 (E.Ammereller), Ch.7 The demand for synoptic representation and the private-language discussion – PI 243-315 (S.Schroeder)

Part II. Ch. 8 ‘Philosophy states only what everyone admits’ (A.Kenny), Ch.9 The use of ‘theory’ in philosophy (O.Hanfling), Ch.10 Criss-cross philosophy (C.Diamond), Ch.11 All kinds of nonsense (H.-J.Glock), Ch.12 A picture held me captive (S.G.Shanker)

 

 

Last revised: April 25th, 2005